How to Have a Difficult Conversation at Work: A Practical Guide for Managers
We all have one.
The conversation that's been sitting on the to-do list for weeks. The one you've rehearsed in the shower, in the car and at 2am. The one that gets heavier every time you look at it.
Here's the uncomfortable truth: that conversation doesn't get easier with time. It gets more expensive.
The good news is that difficult conversations are a skill, not a personality trait. Nobody is born brilliant at them. But with a bit of preparation and a simple structure, they go a lot better than the version playing in your head. Here's how.

What counts as a difficult conversation?
A difficult conversation is any conversation where the stakes feel high and emotions might run high too. In growing businesses, the most common ones are:
• performance that isn't where it needs to be
• a behaviour that's affecting the team (the tone in meetings, the missed start times, the eye-rolls everyone has noticed)
• conflict between team members
• personal circumstances that are starting to affect someone's work
• news someone won't want to hear, like a promotion that isn't happening yet or a change to their role.
They all have one thing in common. It's very tempting to wait and hope they sort themselves out.
Why avoiding it costs more
When a manager avoids a tricky conversation, three things usually happen.
First, the person doesn't know. It sounds obvious, but people can't fix something nobody has told them about. More often than you'd think, the person at the centre of the issue has no idea how serious it's become.
Second, the team is watching. When a behaviour goes unchecked, everyone notices, especially your best people. They start to wonder why the standards apply to them and not to everyone else. That's how resentment builds and how good people may start looking elsewhere.
Third, small issues grow. A quick, informal chat in week one can become a formal process by month three. By then it's no longer a conversation. It's a process, with all the time, stress and risk that comes with it.
There's a safety angle too. Things like unclear roles, unresolved conflict and poor support are recognised psychosocial hazards, and employers have a responsibility to manage them. Dealing with issues early isn't just good management. It's part of keeping people safe at work.
Before: five steps to prepare
1. Get clear on the facts. What happened, when, and how often? Write down specific examples. Aim for examples, not adjectives. "You've missed three deadlines this month" is something you can discuss. "You seem disengaged" is an opinion, and it'll probably get you an argument.
2. Know the outcome you want. What does good look like after this conversation? Try to write it in one sentence. For example: "I want Sam to understand the impact of the missed deadlines, and for us to agree on a plan for the next month."
3. Check your process. If the conversation is about performance or conduct, check what your policies say and whether this is an informal conversation or the start of something more formal. (If you're not sure your policies are up to the job, have a read of HR Documents Every Growing Business Needs.) If there's any chance it could become formal, get advice now, not later.
4. Plan your opening line. The first minute matters most. Write down how you'll open, and make sure it says why you're there. For example: "I want to talk about the last three deadlines, because I'm worried about how things are tracking."
5. Plan to listen. Go in curious, not just ready to talk. There's often more going on than you know. Have a couple of open questions ready, like "How are things looking from your side?" or "What's getting in the way?"
A quick word on logistics. Pick a private space. Allow enough time. Avoid 4:55pm on a Friday, and please don't do it over Slack or email. If it's an informal conversation, a heads-up like "Have you got 20 minutes tomorrow morning? I'd like to chat about how the project handover went" is kinder than "We need to talk."
During: how to run the conversation
Say it in the first minute. Skip the warm-up lap and the feedback sandwich. Small talk before bad news just makes people anxious, and a compliment first means they'll brace for the "but". Be straight and be kind.
Describe, don't diagnose. Talk about what you've seen and the impact it's having, not what you think it says about the person. "The report was late and the client had to chase us" is a fact. "You don't care about this client" is a guess.
Then stop talking. Pause. Let them respond. Silence might feel awkward, but it gives people room to think.
Handle the reaction. People react in all sorts of ways, and that's normal.
• If they're upset, give them a moment. Offer a break if they need one.
• If they're defensive, acknowledge how they feel, then gently bring it back to the examples.
• If they go quiet, ask an open question and wait.
• If things get heated, it's okay to pause and pick it up another time.
Agree on next steps. Before you finish, be clear on what happens now. What needs to change? What support will you give? When will you check in again? Make sure you both leave with the same understanding.
After: follow through
This is where many managers drop the ball, and it's where the real change happens.
• Write it down the same day. Note the date, what you discussed and what you agreed. Keep it brief and factual.
• Follow up in writing if it helps. A short, friendly email summarising what you agreed can avoid confusion later.
• Check in. Check on how they're going, not just on the issue. A tough conversation can knock people around, so remind them about your Employee Assistance Program if you have one.
• Notice the improvement. When things get better, say so. It's the most overlooked part of the whole process.
When it needs to become a formal process
Sometimes one conversation isn't enough. If an issue keeps coming up after informal conversations, if the behaviour is serious, or if there's any chance the situation could end in dismissal, it's time for a more formal process.
A fair formal process usually means setting out the expectations clearly in writing, giving the person a reasonable time and support to improve, giving them a genuine chance to respond, and letting them bring a support person to formal meetings.
This is exactly where good intentions come unstuck. Get advice before you start a formal process, because getting the process wrong can turn a fixable situation into a much bigger problem. This article is general guidance, not legal advice. Every situation is different.
Make hard conversations smaller
The best way to make difficult conversations easier is to have fewer big ones. When managers are running regular check-ins, setting clear expectations and giving feedback little and often, tricky issues get spotted early, while they're still small. Nobody gets blindsided, and the "difficult" conversation becomes just another conversation.
I've written about the rhythm that makes this happen in The Five Conversations Every Manager Should Be Running
You don't have to work it out alone
If there's a tricky conversation on your list right now, or you'd like your managers to feel more confident handling them, we can help. Building these capabilities in your leadership team is part of what our HR Lift Off program is built for. Book a discovery call and let's talk it through.
